Is my hot water cylinder dying, or does it just need a repair?

A cylinder that's running out of hot water often has a cheap part failing, but a leak from the tank itself only ends one way.

Team KettleMonday, 16 November 20262 min read
Why we're writing about this now

Summer showers are shorter and cooler, so cylinder problems hide until winter. Late spring is the low-stress time to find out what's wrong, before a cold morning forces a rushed replacement.

In this post · 6 sections
  1. Parts that fail and can be replaced
  2. When it's the end
  3. The pipe outside that drips
  4. Replacing: low or mains pressure?
  5. What it costs
  6. What to send so it's quick to quote

The hot water runs out halfway through a shower, or it's lukewarm, or there's a puddle in the cupboard. The first thought is a whole new cylinder. Sometimes that's right. But plenty of cylinder problems come down to a part that costs a fraction of the tank.

Parts that fail and can be replaced

  • Element: the heating element burns out. Symptom: no hot water or barely warm.
  • Thermostat: sticks or fails. Symptom: water too hot, not hot enough, or the power tripping.
  • Valves: pressure and temperature relief valves can drip or stick. Symptom: water dribbling from a pipe outside, often the overflow.
  • Wetback or gas components, if you have them.

Electrical parts of a cylinder involve mains power, so element and thermostat work needs the right qualifications. Many plumbers who do cylinders are set up for it; ask when you book.

When it's the end

If water is leaking from the tank itself, not a valve or fitting, the cylinder has corroded through. That can't be fixed. Rust-coloured hot water, or a cylinder that's very old and starting to weep around the base, are signs it's on its way out. A leaking cylinder can damage floors and walls, so don't let it drip for weeks.

The pipe outside that drips

Most cylinders have a relief valve that lets off water when pressure or temperature gets too high, and a pipe that carries it outside. A small drip during heating can be normal for some systems. A steady flow isn't. It wastes hot water and power, and it's telling you a valve or the thermostat needs attention.

Replacing: low or mains pressure?

If you do replace, it's a chance to change the system. Many older New Zealand homes have low-pressure cylinders, which give weak showers. Switching to mains pressure usually means a different cylinder and valves, and sometimes pipework that can handle the pressure. Ask the plumber whether your existing pipes are suitable.

What it costs

Kettle's cost guide for plumbers puts rates at $80 to $150 an hour, with an ordinary job running from about $150 to $800, typically around $350. A valve or element replacement is an ordinary job. A full cylinder replacement is bigger and usually quoted separately, including the cylinder, valves and removal of the old one.

What to send so it's quick to quote

  • A photo of the cylinder and the label with its make, size and age.
  • What's happening: no hot water, lukewarm, leaking, dripping outside.
  • Where the cylinder is and how easy it is to get to.
  • Whether it's low or mains pressure, if you know.
  • Whether there's gas or a wetback.

The takeawayFind out whether the leak or fault is in a part or the tank. Parts get replaced; a leaking tank gets replaced too, but on your schedule if you catch it early.

Got a plumbing job like this?
Tell us what needs doing. Local businesses send you quotes, and nothing is booked until you say yes.
Tell us the job
For plumbing businesses
Do plumbing work?

Customers who post on Kettle get quotes from local businesses, and the ones that reply first with a clear price tend to get the job.

Get jobs like these on Kettle

Questions people ask

How do I know if my hot water cylinder needs replacing?

A leak from the tank itself, rusty hot water, or weeping around the base usually means replacement. No hot water or lukewarm water is often a part that can be fixed.

Why is water dripping from a pipe outside my house?

It is often the relief valve on the hot water cylinder. A steady flow means a valve or thermostat needs checking.

Can I switch from low pressure to mains pressure hot water?

Often yes, but it may need a new cylinder, new valves and pipework rated for the pressure. A plumber can assess your system.

Keep reading

More on plumbing.

All plumbing posts →