Why is my ceiling stain nowhere near where the roof is leaking?

Water travels along framing and underlay before it drips, so the stain tells you where the water stopped, not where it got in.

Team KettleMonday, 16 November 20262 min read
Why we're writing about this now

Spring storms and summer downpours find the weak spots in a roof. If you've seen a new stain after recent rain, late spring is a good time to find the cause, before the next round of wet weather.

In this post · 7 sections
  1. How water travels
  2. The usual suspects
  3. Tracing it from inside
  4. Why sealant isn't a fix
  5. Stay off the roof
  6. What it costs
  7. What to send so it's quick to quote

A brown stain appears on the lounge ceiling after heavy rain. Someone climbs up and looks at the roof directly above it, finds nothing wrong, and puts some sealant on a screw just in case. The stain keeps growing. The leak was a long way up the roof all along.

How water travels

Water that gets through the roof doesn't fall straight down. It runs along the underside of the roofing, along the building paper or underlay, down rafters and across ceiling joists, and drips off at the lowest point. The stain shows where it finally fell. The entry point is usually higher up the slope.

The usual suspects

  • Flashings: where the roof meets walls, chimneys, skylights and other roofs.
  • Penetrations: pipes, flues and vents that go through the roof.
  • Fixings: old screws or nails with perished washers.
  • Valleys and gutters: blocked or rusted, overflowing back under the roofing.
  • Laps: where sheets overlap, especially on low-pitched roofs.
  • Cracked or slipped tiles.

Tracing it from inside

If your roof space is safe to get into, go up after rain with a torch. Look for wet timber, water marks or drips, and follow them uphill. Stay on the joists, as you'll go through the ceiling otherwise. If the stain is in a room with no roof space above it, like under a skillion roof, the roofer will need to trace it from outside.

Why sealant isn't a fix

A tube of sealant can buy time on a small problem, but it breaks down in UV and doesn't fix a badly designed flashing or a corroded sheet. Many roofers will tell you a lot of the leaks they're called to are caused by previous sealant repairs that trapped water.

Stay off the roof

Roofs are dangerous, especially wet ones, steep ones, and fragile ones like old tiles or clear sheeting. Falls from roofs cause serious injuries. Look from a ladder at the gutter line if you must, and leave the rest to someone with the right gear.

What it costs

Kettle's cost guide for roofers puts rates at $60 to $100 an hour, with an ordinary job running from about $800 to $12,000, typically around $3,500. Finding and fixing a single leak sits towards the bottom; replacing flashings or sections of roof pushes it up.

What to send so it's quick to quote

  • Photos of the stain and of the roof from the ground.
  • Roof type: corrugated iron, long-run, tiles or membrane.
  • When the leak shows up: every rain, or only in wind-driven rain.
  • Anything on the roof near the stain: chimney, skylight, flue.
  • Roughly how old the roof is.

The takeawayLook uphill from the stain. The leak is almost always higher than where the water lands.

Got a roofing job like this?
Tell us what needs doing. Local businesses send you quotes, and nothing is booked until you say yes.
Tell us the job
For roofing businesses
Do roofing work?

Customers who post on Kettle get quotes from local businesses, and the ones that reply first with a clear price tend to get the job.

Get jobs like these on Kettle

Questions people ask

Why does my roof only leak when it's windy?

Wind-driven rain can push water up under laps and flashings that cope with normal rain. A roofer can check those details.

Is roof sealant a permanent fix?

Usually not. Sealant breaks down over time and can trap water. A proper repair fixes the flashing or fixing that failed.

How do I find where my roof is leaking?

Look in the roof space after rain for wet timber and follow it uphill. A roofer can trace leaks from outside.

Keep reading

More on roofing.

All roofing posts →