Builder or carpenter for my deck, and where does the money actually go?

Most deck bills are decided underneath the boards, so knowing what sits under yours tells you who to call and what a fair quote looks like.

Team KettleMonday, 16 November 20264 min read
Why we're writing about this now

NIWA's outlook for November 2026 to January 2027 expects a very strong El Niño, with above-average temperatures across the North Island and the east of the South Island. That means more evenings outside, and a deck that will be in use from now to February. Book the work before the season starts, not halfway through it.

In this post · 6 sections
  1. Start underneath, with a torch and a screwdriver
  2. Carpenter or builder: the honest split
  3. What it costs, and where the money goes
  4. The timber detail most people never ask about
  5. Doing it yourself
  6. What to send so it's quick to quote

Here's the mistake that costs people the most: they ring someone to replace the tired, grey boards, the boards come up, and the joists underneath are soft. Now the quote has doubled, the barbecue is on the lawn and the old timber is in a pile by the letterbox. Nearly every surprise on a deck job lives in the frame, not the surface you walk on.

So before you work out who to call, work out what you've actually got.

Start underneath, with a torch and a screwdriver

Get down and look at the structure. You're checking three things: the piles, the bearers and joists, and the fixings that hold it all together. Push a screwdriver into the timber at the ends of joists and where they sit on bearers, because that's where water collects and rot starts. If it sinks in easily, that piece is done.

  • Piles: do they move when you push them, and is the ground around them soft or washed out?
  • Joists and bearers: any soft spots, splits or black staining where boards meet the frame?
  • Fixings: rust streaks or bolts you can turn by hand mean the steel is losing the fight with the weather, especially near the coast.
  • The ledger, where the deck attaches to the house: this is the one that matters most, and the one people never look at.

If everything underneath is firm and only the boards are tired, you have a resurfacing job. If the frame is going, you have a rebuild, even if the top looks fine.

Carpenter or builder: the honest split

A carpenter is the right call for replacing boards, swapping out a few rotten joists, new steps, balustrades and general repairs on a frame that's basically sound. A builder makes more sense when the job changes the structure: new piles, a bigger or higher deck, anything attached to the house in a new way, or work that needs a building consent. Plenty of builders do small deck jobs and plenty of carpenters are qualified builders, so the label matters less than whether they've done your kind of job recently. Ask them.

On consent, the rule of thumb is that a low deck close to the ground is often exempt, while a higher one needs a proper barrier and may need consent. The detail depends on height and what the deck is attached to, so check with your council or ask the person quoting to confirm in writing which side of the line your job sits on.

What it costs, and where the money goes

Kettle's cost guide for carpenters puts rates at $50 to $90 an hour, with an ordinary job running from about $500 to $8,000, typically around $2,500. For builders the guide gives $55 to $100 an hour, with an ordinary job running from about $2,000 to $30,000, typically around $8,000.

That gap tells you something. Board replacement and repairs tend to sit in carpenter territory; anything that means new structure pushes into builder territory. Within either range, the money goes in roughly this order: labour, then framing timber and fixings, then the decking itself, then removing and dumping the old stuff. That last line is easy to forget and it is never free. Ask whether disposal is in the quote.

The timber detail most people never ask about

Treated pine comes in different grades for different jobs, and the grade stamped on the timber matters more than the brand of the boards. Timber above ground, like joists and boards, is usually H3.2. Anything in the ground needs a higher grade, and piles that hold the structure up need H5. A cheap quote that reuses old piles, or uses the wrong grade in the ground, can look fine for a couple of summers before it starts to sink.

The other trick is spacing. New boards are often still wet from treatment and shrink as they dry, and a hot, dry summer speeds that up. A good carpenter lays them with that in mind. If you're doing it yourself, ask at the timber yard how dry the boards are before you decide on the gap.

Doing it yourself

Replacing a handful of boards on a sound frame is a fair weekend job if you own a drop saw and don't mind kneeling. Oiling or staining is very doable too. Stop at structure: piles, ledgers, anything holding people above a drop. A deck that fails tends to fail all at once, usually with a crowd on it.

What to send so it's quick to quote

  • Photos from above, plus at least one from underneath showing the frame and piles.
  • Rough length, width and height off the ground. A tape measure and a guess are fine.
  • What you want: new boards only, repairs, a full rebuild or something bigger.
  • Any soft spots you found with the screwdriver, and where.
  • Whether it's attached to the house, and how easy it is to get timber to it.
  • Your timing, if you want it done before a particular date.

The takeawayLook underneath before you ask anyone to quote. Ten minutes with a torch tells you whether you need a carpenter for a resurface or a builder for a rebuild, and it means the price you approve is the price you pay, not the opening bid before the boards come up.

Got a decks and building job like this?
Tell us what needs doing. Local businesses send you quotes, and nothing is booked until you say yes.
Tell us the job
For decks and building businesses
Customers are asking for decks and building work right now

Decks get fixed before the barbecue season. Customers who post on Kettle get quotes from local businesses, and the ones that reply first with a clear price tend to get the job.

Open for quotes now
Get jobs like these on Kettle

Questions people ask

Do I need a building consent for a deck in New Zealand?

Low decks close to the ground are often exempt, but higher decks need a barrier and may need consent. It depends on height and how the deck attaches to the house, so check with your council or get the builder to confirm in writing.

How much does a carpenter cost per hour in NZ?

Kettle's cost guide for carpenters puts rates at $50 to $90 an hour. An ordinary job runs from about $500 to $8,000, typically around $2,500.

Can I just replace the deck boards and keep the old frame?

Yes, if the frame is sound. Check joists, bearers and piles with a screwdriver first; if the timber is soft, new boards on an old frame is money wasted.

What treated timber should be used for deck piles?

Piles that support a structure need H5 treated timber. Joists and boards above the ground are usually H3.2, and the grade is stamped on the timber.

Keep reading

More on decks and building.

All decks and building posts →